My friend Sankar and I conducted a small experiment to evaluate ChatGPT and Bard Vs. human expertise. My human expertise is reflected through the book I have published recently: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0BV49NPNQ We chose four questions that require considerable learning and reflection in the topic of “Spirituality”. Sankar asked the four questions and compiled the answers from the two AI tools. I sent him my answers independently and without any knowledge of the responses from Chat GPT or BARD.
Below are the assessments of all three from Sankar, who has an interest in the topic but does not have formal education or in-depth knowledge on the subject area.
Sankar’s evaluation:
Thanks a lot for sharing. I have pasted the answers from BARD and ChatGPT in the shared doc together with your (Subbu) inputs:
Q1: What is spirituality?
Definition of spirituality: yours is spot on and direct, (KBI);
none of them matches the depth you have gone.
Q2: Difference between that and religion?
I find chatGPT to be more mature but not to your level 🙂
If i had not seen your answer, i would be extremely impressed by its response.
Q3, Which is better?
BARD completely failed, while chatGPT gave a very insightful answer that is more simple and easy to understand. But it didn’t match the concise answer you gave. chatGPT has definitely understood various benefits of religion and spirituality; was able to highlight it.
Q4: Summarize vedic philosophy?
chatGPT didn’t do well here. It failed to connect the enabler and enabled like you did.
To be honest, if I had not seen your response, I would think chatGPT did a wonderful job 🙂
1. What is spirituality?
Subbu:
Spirituality is a way of thinking. It can lead to a way of life known as Spiritual life.
When we think of “reality” we refer to something – thoughts, ideas and actions – based or rooted in real facts, concrete evidence. Reality is opposed to imaginary, just made up or illusion.
In a similar fashion we can think of “Spirituality” as our way of thinking with its foundation based on the “Spirit” or the driving force that enables anything. It requires self-reflection, to stand back and look at anything as detached from our “Self”. This self-reflection leads us to understand that everything we know is based on our Knowledge, Bias and Ignorance. The dominance of one of these three connectors make us Tranquil, Turbulent or Inertial.
Self-reflection also leads us to comprehend that everything we know or relate to, are enabled by an infinite set of laws of nature, both known as well as unknown. Vedic Philosophy describes all this collection of the laws of nature – the enabler, the driver or the spirit – as Brahman.
Hence Spirituality is a way of thinking to reflect upon our connection to anything through the three connectors and the enabler of these connections.
Our connection to our K, B and I and their relative roles change every moment like the ocean waves. The enablers, the spirit or the laws of nature are ever present under these waves like the calm deep ocean. Both aspects – the varying aspects (which we call life) and the foundation or enabler/spirit are one and the same. They are like the waves on the top and deep ocean supporting the waves – all part of the same water. Ocean waves never die. Changes in our life do not stop either. This ability to see unity across diversity and understanding of the changes in our life is the essential outcome of Spirituality. We understand our life and all the good/bad, happy/sorrow, etc. and why they are that way thanks to K, B and I. We also comprehend that everything (good/bad, happy/sorrow) are all the effects of the laws of nature. Such reflection and understanding promotes a peaceful mind, calm and contended. With such thinking and mindset any spiritual person lives with peace and harmony within and cohesive and collaboration with all that surrounds us!
Reflecting on the connectors and managing them to drive our life may be thought of as “Self-control”. Unbridled allegiance to the enablers (laws of nature) which we can only know through their effects – like that which enables the wind to move things is seen by things being blown away, or the buoyancy that enables things to float, etc. – may be described as unattached active engagement. Hence Spirituality may be defined as “A way of life that progresses from Self-control to total self-control to unattached active engagement” (i.e.) living like nature!
[BARD v1.0.0 response]
Spirituality is a broad concept that refers to the human search for meaning, purpose, and connection in life. It is often associated with religion, but it can also exist independently of religious beliefs. Spirituality can be expressed through a variety of practices, such as prayer, meditation, service to others, and spending time in nature.
There is no one definition of spirituality that is universally agreed upon. However, some common elements of spirituality include:
- A belief in something greater than oneself
- A sense of connection to something larger than the self, such as nature, the universe, or God
- A search for meaning and purpose in life
- A focus on the present moment
- A sense of peace and well-being
Spirituality can be a source of great comfort and strength in times of difficulty. It can also help people to live more fulfilling and meaningful lives.
Here are some of the benefits of spirituality:
- Increased well-being
- Reduced stress and anxiety
- Improved sleep
- Enhanced relationships
- Greater compassion and empathy
- Increased sense of purpose
- Stronger resilience
- A more positive outlook on life
If you are interested in exploring spirituality, there are many resources available to help you get started. You can talk to friends, family, or religious leaders. You can also read books, articles, or websites about spirituality. There are also many classes and workshops available that can help you learn more about spirituality and how to incorporate it into your life.
[chatGPT 3.5]
Spirituality is a broad and multifaceted concept that encompasses various beliefs, practices, and experiences related to the inner essence of individuals and their connection to something greater than themselves. It is often associated with matters of the soul, higher consciousness, and the search for meaning and purpose in life.
While spirituality can be influenced by religious traditions, it is not limited to organized religion. Many people find spirituality through personal exploration, introspection, and contemplative practices. It involves the exploration of one’s inner self, the pursuit of transcendence, and the development of a deeper understanding of life and the universe.
Spirituality can involve the belief in a higher power, divine presence, or universal energy. It may also encompass the exploration of philosophical and existential questions, the practice of meditation and mindfulness, the cultivation of virtues such as compassion and gratitude, and the pursuit of personal growth and self-realization.
Spirituality is often seen as a deeply personal and subjective experience, with individuals having their unique paths and interpretations. It can provide a sense of connection, inner peace, and purpose, helping individuals navigate life’s challenges, find solace in times of hardship, and cultivate a greater sense of well-being and fulfillment.
It’s important to note that spirituality means different things to different people, and there is no single definition or framework that encompasses all its aspects. It is a deeply personal journey that can take various forms and be influenced by cultural, philosophical, and individual differences.
2. Difference between that and religion?
Subbu:
The essential requirement for Spirituality is an objective Self-reflection on the connectors (K, B and I) and their inter-play. It also requires exploring the enablers, laws of nature where we can and accept them (faith) even when we are not clear or do not know about them. This is described above as “Self-control” and “unattached active engagement”.
As scientists and professionals we practice these two – reflecting on the connectors and exploring the basic principles. Our education is the pathway for such exploration.
Most religions start with a faith – belief in a God or creator – followed by rules and rituals to calm our mind leading to self reflection. Hence religion, like any form of secular education may be thought of as a means towards self-reflection and un-attached active engagement.
Both secular education and religion are pathways towards “Spirituality”. But neither are the end by themselves for a strong mind seeking peace and harmony within and cohesion and collaboration with all that surrounds us. This end requires an understanding of Spirituality and its application in daily life (i.e.) Spirituality in practice.
[BARD v1.0.0 response]
Sorry, I need more information like what religions you are talking about?
Here are some of the key differences between different religions:
Beliefs: Different religions have different beliefs about the nature of God, the universe, and the afterlife. For example, Christians believe in one God who created the universe, while Hindus believe in many gods and goddesses.
Practices: Different religions have different practices, such as prayer, meditation, and rituals. For example, Muslims pray five times a day, while Buddhists meditate to achieve enlightenment.
Texts: Different religions have different sacred texts, such as the Bible, the Quran, and the Vedas. These texts are believed to contain the teachings of the religion’s founder or founders.
Leadership: Different religions have different leaders, such as priests, rabbis, and imams. These leaders are responsible for leading the religion’s community and interpreting its teachings.
Community: Different religions have different communities, which provide support and fellowship for their members. These communities can be local, national, or international in scope.
It is important to note that there is a great deal of diversity within each religion. Not all Christians believe the same things, and not all Muslims practice their religion in the same way. It is also important to remember that not everyone identifies with a religion. Some people are atheists, agnostics, or simply spiritual but not religious.
It is up to each individual to decide what they believe and how they want to practice their faith. There is no right or wrong answer, and there is no one way to be religious.
[chatGPT 3.5]
The difference between spirituality and religion lies in their focus, structure, and often their relationship to organized institutions:
Focus: Spirituality tends to emphasize personal inner experiences, self-discovery, and the individual’s relationship with the divine or something greater than themselves. It is often more fluid and adaptable, allowing for personal interpretations and eclectic beliefs. Religion, on the other hand, typically revolves around organized systems of beliefs, rituals, practices, and community engagement. It often involves adherence to specific doctrines, scriptures, and codes of conduct.
Structure: Spirituality is often less formal and less structured than religion. It may involve individual practices such as meditation, mindfulness, prayer, or other personal rituals. Spirituality can be pursued outside of any organized religious institution or in conjunction with one. Religion, on the other hand, tends to have established hierarchies, institutions, and formalized practices such as worship services, ceremonies, and specific religious leaders.
Institutionalization: While spirituality can exist independently of religious institutions, religion is often associated with organized institutions and communities. Religions typically have formalized structures, religious leaders, places of worship, and organized systems for transmitting and preserving their beliefs and practices. Spirituality can be more individualistic and subjective, not necessarily requiring participation in organized religious communities.
Belief systems: Religion often involves adherence to a specific set of beliefs, doctrines, and dogmas that define the teachings and principles of that particular faith. These beliefs are often shared among the members of the religious community and provide a framework for their worldview and moral guidelines. Spirituality, on the other hand, allows for a broader range of beliefs and interpretations, which can vary widely from person to person.
It’s important to note that spirituality and religion are not mutually exclusive. Many religious individuals also have a strong sense of personal spirituality, while some individuals may identify as spiritual without adhering to any specific religious tradition. The distinction between spirituality and religion can vary depending on individual perspectives and cultural contexts.
3. Which is better?
Subbu:
The question which is better arises when we think of religion and spirituality as alternatives.
When we say, “I have an apple and orange, which is better?”, we understand that both belong to varieties of fruits. When we say “which is better – soil or fruit?”, the question has no significance as the soil is a material object on which plants grow and the trees that grow yield the fruit! In a similar vein, religion may be thought of as a means, a source that could nurture and develop spirituality.
As stated in the answer to earlier question, religion is a means, a preparatory tool for self reflection and implicit faith on something we can only infer through the effects but can not describe. Any source of light leads to a shadow. We understand light and shadow as visual/optical aspects of nature. This understanding comes from “faith”. Religion is a means to promote our ability to think and reflect on all that is cognitive as well as promote our acceptance – faith – of the universe of laws of nature (Brahman), the enabler.
[BARD v1.0.0 response]
Spirituality and religion are both important aspects of human life. They can provide comfort, guidance, and a sense of purpose.
Spirituality is a broader term that refers to the human search for meaning, purpose, and connection in life. It is often associated with religion, but it can also exist independently of religious beliefs. Spirituality can be expressed through a variety of practices, such as prayer, meditation, service to others, and spending time in nature.
Religion is a more specific term that refers to a set of beliefs and practices that are usually shared by a community or group. Religion often includes a belief in a higher power, a set of rituals and practices, and a community of believers.
There is no one answer to the question of which is “better,” being spiritual or religious. Both can be beneficial to people’s lives. Ultimately, the best approach is to find what works best for you.
Here are some of the benefits of spirituality:
- Increased well-being
- Reduced stress and anxiety
- Improved sleep
- Enhanced relationships
- Greater compassion and empathy
- Increased sense of purpose
- Stronger resilience
- A more positive outlook on life
Here are some of the benefits of religion:
- A sense of community
- A sense of belonging
- A sense of purpose
- A sense of hope
- A sense of meaning
- A sense of peace
- A sense of comfort
If you are interested in exploring spirituality or religion, there are many resources available to help you get started. You can talk to friends, family, or religious leaders. You can also read books, articles, or websites about spirituality and religion. There are also many classes and workshops available that can help you learn more about spirituality and religion and how to incorporate them into your life.
[chatGPT 3.5]
Determining whether being spiritual or religious is “good” is subjective and dependent on individual beliefs, values, and needs. Both spirituality and religion can offer various benefits and fulfill different aspects of people’s lives. It’s important to recognize that what works for one person may not work for another, and personal preferences and experiences can greatly influence one’s choice.
Here are some considerations:
Personal Connection: Spirituality often emphasizes personal connection and individual exploration. It can provide a sense of inner peace, self-discovery, and a deepened understanding of oneself and the world. If you value personal autonomy, flexibility, and a more open-ended approach to spirituality, focusing on personal spirituality might be beneficial for you.
Community and Support: Religion often provides a strong sense of community, shared beliefs, and support systems. It offers opportunities for communal worship, social interaction, and a sense of belonging. If you value a structured community and appreciate the support and guidance that organized religious institutions can provide, religious involvement might be more suitable for you.
Rituals and Traditions: Religion often offers established rituals, ceremonies, and traditions that provide a sense of continuity and cultural heritage. These rituals can provide comfort, a sense of order, and a shared connection to a larger historical and cultural context. If you find meaning and solace in ritualistic practices and enjoy participating in structured ceremonies, religion might be a good fit for you.
Moral and Ethical Framework: Religion often provides a comprehensive moral and ethical framework, guiding individuals on how to live their lives based on religious teachings and scriptures. If you value clear moral guidelines and a well-defined ethical system, religion may align with your beliefs and values.
Ultimately, the decision between being spiritual or religious is a personal one. It’s important to consider your own beliefs, values, needs, and preferences. Many people find fulfillment and meaning in a combination of spirituality and religious practices, while others find their path solely in one or the other. It’s essential to respect and honor the choices and paths of others, as long as they promote personal well-being, growth, and respect for others.
4. Summarize vedic philosophy?
Subbu:
Please see:
Vedic Philosophy may be summarized as:
Universe can be seen as a two sided coin – enabler and the enabled
From the “enabler” side, the Grand Pronouncements from Upanishads reverberate:
Aham Brahma: I am Brahman
Tat Twam Asi: You and the Universe are one and the same.
Prajnanam Brahma: Consciousness is Brahman.
The “enabler” is the infinite laws of nature collectively identified as “Brahman”.
On this side “I am, therefore I think”.
From the “enabled” side all that exists are reflections of the laws of Nature (i.e.) Brahman.
Sarvam Brahma Mayam: Everything is enabled by and are evidence of the Laws of Nature
They are also reflected in human thoughts through the coexisting connectors: Knowledge, Bias and Ignorance and their interplay.
On this side “I think, therefore I am”.
I am a product of my thoughts, leading to my emotions and actions.
I am a product of my “experiences”.
On the enabler side “Total Self-control and unattached active engagement (Tat Sath Brahmarpanam Astu)” is its very nature.
On the enabled side: “Total self-control and unattached active engagement” is the nature of everything as they instinctively follow the laws of nature. This includes all physical or tangible aspects of humans (body, mind and intellect).
Humans follow the laws of nature implicitly just as the material objects, plants and animals do, along with the human brain/mind enabled by thought. Following the laws of nature is the goal in managing our thoughts through the connectors (Guna) and their equilibrium states. It is reflected as Divinity – allegiance to laws of nature – in the manner, outcome and behavior of the person.
“I” as an individual or the “ego” is not part of Vedic Philosophy or thought. It is with this understanding devoid of “ego” one can see everything being an integral part of the enabler – Brahman – Laws of Nature. It is our need to see “I” – the human or individual distinct from the rest that requires concepts of Soul, God, Birth, Death, reincarnation, etc.
We can not avoid being “I” as enabled by our mind and hence our thoughts leading to the connectors (K,B and I) and their equilibrium states (Tranquility, Turbulence and Inertial).Hence being subjective – with opinions and judgment – is our very nature. At the same time we can acknowledge that all aspects of who we are – including our thinking and thoughts – are enabled. Car and the driver are distinct from each other. But, we are both the car and driver at the same time! In a self-driving car, the car and driver are both enabled by human beings. As humans our car (Body/mind/intellect complex) and our driver are both enabled by laws of nature (Sarvam Brahma Mayam). We are a subset thinking and acting as enablers within a larger universe of enabled!
This true and genuine recognition of “I” as indistinguishable from Brahman – Nature, as a whole – is acknowledged in the Prayer song for Athma Bodha (Knowledge of the Self) by Swami Adi Sankaracharya:
Pratah smarami hridi samsphura tatwam
Satchitsukham paramahamsa gatim turiyam
Yat swapna jagara sushupta mavaiti nityam
Tad brahma nishkalamaham na cha bhuta sanghaha.
I offer my prayers to that Nature (Brahman – which has no properties, Good or Bad, hence blemishless), which exists beyond my physical states (of being awake, asleep or dreaming).
“I” am that Brahman, that is eternal, ever present and omnipresent (without beginning or end or birth and death), not the one perceived as attached to the material objects (Bhuta Sangaha).
[BARD response]
Vedic philosophy is a system of thought that originated in ancient India. It is based on the Vedas, a collection of sacred texts that are over 3,000 years old. Vedic philosophy is concerned with the nature of reality, the purpose of life, and the path to liberation.
One of the central concepts of Vedic philosophy is the idea of Brahman. Brahman is the ultimate reality, the ground of all being. It is beyond human understanding, but it can be experienced through meditation and other spiritual practices.
Another important concept in Vedic philosophy is the idea of Atman. Atman is the individual soul. It is eternal and unchanging. Atman is not separate from Brahman, but it is obscured by ignorance. The goal of spiritual practice is to overcome ignorance and realize the identity of Atman and Brahman.
Vedic philosophy also teaches about the law of karma. Karma is the law of cause and effect. It states that every action has a reaction. Good actions lead to good results, and bad actions lead to bad results. The goal of spiritual practice is to break the cycle of karma and achieve liberation.
Vedic philosophy is a rich and complex system of thought. It has influenced many other religions and philosophies, including Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism. It continues to be a source of inspiration and guidance for millions of people around the world.
Here are some of the key tenets of Vedic philosophy:
- The universe is a manifestation of Brahman, the ultimate reality.
- Atman, the individual soul, is eternal and unchanging.
- Karma, the law of cause and effect, governs the universe.
- The goal of life is to achieve moksha, liberation from the cycle of birth and death.
Vedic philosophy is a powerful and inspiring system of thought that can help us to understand our place in the universe and to live a more fulfilling life.
[chatGPT 3.5]
Vedic philosophy refers to the philosophical ideas and concepts found in the ancient Indian scriptures known as the Vedas. Here is a summarized overview of Vedic philosophy:
The Vedas: The Vedas are considered the oldest sacred texts in Hinduism, composed in ancient Sanskrit. They are divided into four main texts: the Rigveda, Yajurveda, Samaveda, and Atharvaveda. The Vedas contain hymns, rituals, prayers, and philosophical speculations.
Brahman: Vedic philosophy asserts the concept of Brahman, the ultimate reality and underlying principle of the universe. Brahman is described as an eternal, infinite, and impersonal existence that encompasses everything in the cosmos.
Atman: Vedic philosophy recognizes the concept of Atman, which refers to the individual self or soul. Atman is believed to be identical to Brahman in its essence, representing the individual’s true nature that transcends the physical body and mind.
Karma: Vedic philosophy introduces the concept of Karma, the law of cause and effect. It suggests that one’s actions, intentions, and thoughts have consequences that shape their present and future experiences. Good actions lead to positive outcomes, while negative actions lead to suffering.
Dharma: Dharma is a central concept in Vedic philosophy, representing one’s moral and ethical duties, righteousness, and social responsibilities. It emphasizes living in harmony with cosmic order and following one’s caste and stage of life duties.
Moksha: Vedic philosophy places great importance on the pursuit of Moksha, liberation from the cycle of birth and death (samsara). It is the ultimate goal, wherein the individual realizes their true nature as Brahman and transcends the cycle of reincarnation.
Yoga: Vedic philosophy encompasses various paths and practices to attain spiritual realization and Moksha. Yoga, meaning “union” or “integration,” involves techniques such as meditation, breath control (pranayama), ethical disciplines (yamas and niyamas), and physical postures (asanas) to purify the mind and body, and achieve spiritual growth.
Vedanta: Vedanta is a prominent school of thought within Vedic philosophy. It focuses on the Upanishads, which are philosophical texts within the Vedas. Vedanta explores the nature of reality, the relationship between Brahman and Atman, and the means to realize one’s true nature.
It’s important to note that Vedic philosophy encompasses a wide range of ideas and interpretations, and different philosophical schools and teachers may emphasize certain aspects of Vedic thought. Additionally, Vedic philosophy has influenced and interacted with other philosophical and religious traditions in India over time, leading to the development of various philosophical systems.
Spirituality In Practice 
Leave a comment